top of page

K–12 Publishers: Build Superhuman Staff, Not Hollow AI Content

Brett Hodus
15 hours ago
6 min read
Illustration of a professional woman of color flying like a superhero in a business suit and cape, carrying a laptop.

The appeal of AI content creation is obvious. Comparable content built faster, with fewer internal resources and lower production costs.

Across educational publishing, and inside of school district content buildouts, teams have been experimenting with AI in different ways. Some have empowered AI authoring tools, leaned into editorial support, built AI templates, and even experimented with AI-illustrations. Other companies have leaned in further through a mountain of ed-tech funding, building content-generation engines that in essence make educators publishers.

Generally, companies are taking advantage of cost reductions through reduced staff as they integrate AI into their internal production processes in their own way. They are chasing efficiencies driven by human oversight of AI that preserves quality and reduces costs.

So, is it working? It may be too early to tell.

The strategic industry wide shift into AI began a few years ago but has exploded in 2026. As of today, much of the AI+ human produced educational content has barely reached the market. By next year, publishers will learn even more about what teachers like and don’t like about these AI-hybrid products. That learning will continue as the rollercoaster of adoption and rejection levels out.

A business sustainability question pops up here, and an inconvenient truth may be lurking: adoption of (even partly) AI-generated products in schools is highly volatile and unpredictable. Passions run high on this topic and the winds in education always seem to blow in every direction. This is why executives and production leaders need to be thinking about deploying AI with a thoughtful restraint in the short term, and with an eye on a long term strategy that turns employees into superhumans.

A clever and motivated production team using AI strategically can improve their margins and workflows in incredible ways. But they need to operate within a set of boundaries - a company-wide AI architecture that encourages them to be creative and explore, but to do so with caution and oversight, and with the priority always being maintaining the soul of their work and focusing on the end user (a human being).

Educational publishers who integrate AI carelessly into production workflows without testing results may be surprised to discover that their customers no longer have a compelling reason to seek out their products. This could mean a slow death as their content fades into the background like a ship in a crowded sea of similarly produced products that begin to look like a sort of static to end users. If enough companies follow a fast and loose integration path, the industry’s “AI-arms race” will end with fewer viable publishers, as publishers who slowly hollow out their brand lose their audience and user base.

Educational publishers who have earned their place in the market over the years have done so by creating content that is effective, relevant, interesting, pedagogically sound, easy to implement, and brand identifiable. AI can amplify all of this when deployed as a tool to supercharge human employees. Successful publishers create smart, strategic, and impactful content because of the people who work there. The values they pursue in creating content are often practical. Can a teacher use this lesson without spending an hour repairing it? Does the lesson fit inside of a class period? Are students interested enough to participate and persist? Is the pedagogy sound? Does the instruction help students reach the relevant state and national standards? Do the educators see Publisher X and feel trust?

We have all seen that AI can target every one of the standard curriculum production requirements and many of the values these publishers pursue. AI tools can generate clear lessons, align activities to a standard, suggest differentiation, and produce assessments. The results will appear excellent in a “checklist” review.

However, a classroom asks more of a curriculum than a checklist. Lessons are the blueprints for instructions real-life humans will follow and participate in. Classroom content requires reflections of the human spirit everywhere. This is what makes content that compels learners to engage. Curriculum must be designed for a human to experience. It is illogical to think that this connection can be made by a machine that has never experienced a human experience. Engagement is born in the reflections of humanness and is absolutely critical for any learning to take place. Student effort is often the most significant ingredient of a high test score.

So how should we use AI to build content? And to be clear, we have to find ways to leverage this amazing tool to offer price-competitive content in the future.

Consider Kathy, a curriculum writer who spent fifteen years teaching 3rd grade. While writing curriculum, she chooses one example over another because she is reminded of a personal experience where a student kept getting confused. She cuts another sentence because she hears her voice reading it aloud and a word jumps out at her that she thinks may cause confusion for early readers and ELLs. She changes from another activity because she knows that students tend to get antsy at the end of the period, and she needs to get them on their feet for the last 5 minutes of class.

Her experiences, feelings and memories become inflection points in the curriculum. The writer believes in these decisions the same way she did when she was in front of a classroom full of engaged students as a teacher. Her experiences drive her subconscious to recognize when encouragement sounds patronizing, when an explanation assumes too much, and when a supposedly engaging activity will lose the room. These choices create the groundwork for a human connection to curriculum and a superior product. Contextual human experience and the impact it has on our actions is hard to measure, and extremely difficult for AI to replicate. Kathy anticipates misconceptions, catches tricky language, understands the nuance of a classroom, and is totally accountable for the choices made in the curriculum.

Across any program, there are hundreds of choices curriculum creators make. AI can support this work in so many ways without destroying what makes the curriculum connect with young people. But the best workflows will utilize AI as a supercharger for the employees themselves, to deploy with restraint and skepticism, targeting pedagogically sound products that achieve human connection. AI can draft examples and Kathy can choose the one her experience suggests will work and tweak it based on her experience. AI can flag a readability issue and Kathy can decide if it matters to real students. And so forth.

In essence, publishers should invest in training Kathy how to lean on AI to make her work more efficient, thoughtful, and deep through efficiencies connected to communication, operations, brainstorming, standards alignment, schedules, emails, proofing, and fact-checking. When cost reduction becomes the governing objective it can be easy to be seduced by AI and forget how important humans are in the process. People who use AI as a tool that supercharges their individual work, while amplifying their authentic human spirit, are going to be the greatest assets for publishers in an AI-filled future. These superhumans will rule the day.

Leaders should prioritize (1) training staff to use AI to amplify their experience and work product, (2) testing and revising AI+ human workflows by documenting processes, prompts, and assumptions, alongside results, and (3) talking openly with customers about AI-hybrid produced content, their three highest priorities.

An effective AI vision will require more than simply putting a human approval or clean-up step at the end of an automated task. Experts need the shared vision, time, authority, human discussion, testing, experience, and resources to continually shape their work so that it connects to students. If your experts are fluent in AI tools, act with restraint and care, and build products with soul alongside AI tools, the process is supercharged as are they.

The strategic question for publishing executives today is whether their current AI production investments are strengthening their companies’ long-term value or simply reducing costs in the short term as they approach a cliff they may not see. Savings are welcome, but savings that erode differentiation end up being expensive.

The winners will build an AI architecture that empowers the development of their employees, not one that replaces the human spirit with products students do not connect to.

By Brett Hodus

CEO

Book Buddy Media

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page